Return Policy

Mystique's Return Policy 

*** 2021 Holiday Return period extended through January 15, 2022.  See below for details***

Items in original, unaltered, and unused condition may be returned or exchanged by January 15, 2022. Returns and exchanges must be accompanied by the original packaging and a copy of the sales receipt.

Mystique will issue a refund to the original payment method for the purchase price of the merchandise. Alternately, we can issue a store credit Gift Certificate that can be used at a later date.

Please see exceptions to this policy below:

Special Orders
Special Orders are made exclusively to your specifications, and therefore are not eligible for return or exchange. Special orders include (but are not limited to):

  • Screwback earrings
  • Items listed as Special Order
  • Custom color combinations
  • Custom Design orders

Special Order Ring Sizes
Occasionally, ring sizes listed as Special Order will be in stock. We encourage you to call and check with us!

  • Ladies’ rings smaller than size 5.0
  • Ladies’ rings larger than size 8.0
  • Men’s rings smaller than size 8.0
  • Men’s rings larger than size 10.0
  • Custom ring sizes not in stock

Final Sale Purchases
Final Sale items are not eligible for return or exchange. Final Sale items include (but are not limited to):

  • Items listed as Final Sale
  • Gift Certificates or Gift Cards
  • Loose stones



How to create a Return Request
  1. Log into your Mystique online account.
  2. Go to "My Account" and choose "Orders".
  3. Find the order/item that you need to return. Click on the order number. At the bottom right of the page, click on the "Return" button.
  4. Select the item(s) for return, and please give us feedback about why you are returning. Select a "Return Reason", a "Return Action", and please leave a few comments about why you need to return or exchange.
  5. Click "Submit Return Request". We will reveiw your request and you will get an email within 1 business day with instructions for sending in your return.


Questions or Concerns?

If you have any questions or concerns about your purchase being eligible for return or exchange, we encourage you to contact us.

  • Call us at (800) 778-0080
  • Contact us via email by using the form below: